Independence Day: Stranger than fiction

This website was launched in April of this year to announce my first published work. At that time, my novella The Devil’s Garden had just been accepted by The E-Book Publisher Who Shall Not Be Named (TEBPWSNBN). Five days ago, my editor at TEBPWSNBN had a sudden realization that the publisher had a strict policy against underage sex in their books. This was news to me, and apparently, the first page of my manuscript in which my character’s age and history was very specifically mentioned, was suddenly news to my editor after three months and one round of revisions.
There are a number of things about this epiphany that are particularly odd. The publisher’s submission guidelines as currently listed say nothing at all about underage sex. They do, however, state that nothing glorifying, justifying, or excusing pedophilia will be accepted, a position I wholeheartedly agree with. My editor, however, explained that underage sex, in TEBPWSNBN’s opinion, would somehow do just that.

Strange and outrageous, but that’s their stance. However, my book contains no underage sex. What it contains is a 17-year-old character who is a well-established courtesan in an archaic fantasy setting in which 13 is the age of consent. Because my character was thrown out on the streets at age 12 to fend for herself, the history of the character does include underage sex, but the story does not, unless we’re calling 17 underage, which most of the world does not.

Setting aside the character’s current age and the fact that her history is just that, I was asked to increase her age by six years to make her 18 instead of 12 at the time of being thrown out. I explained that in a world in which the age of marriage was 13, one would not throw out an 18-year-old (an 18-year-old living with parents would be unheard of), and in the strange event that one did get thrown out of one’s home at 18, it would hardly be tragic; finding work would be no more difficult than for any other adult in her society.

I offered to change the initial age to 13, but was told that this was unacceptable. The editor suggested that for the character’s history to imply any kind of sexual activity before the age of 18 would open TEBPWSNBN up to prosecution under US law. If we were not in The Land of Make Believe prior to this statement, we had firmly entered it now.

If I were desperate to be published under any circumstances, perhaps I would have consented to making my story a rather silly tale about an aging courtesan who began her career at the age of 18 after being a drain on her family for the first five years of her adult life. A few people suggested I should let the story go; once written, it was just a commodity, and had no personal meaning. But this story has a great deal of meaning for me. I wrote it in honor of Gwen Araujo, a young trans-woman who was murdered at the age of 17 for being true to who she was.

My publisher had agreed in my contract not to make any material changes to the text of my manuscript, and this was most certainly a material change. I remained firm in my position, and TEBPWSNBN cut me loose.

For me, saying no to this compromise of my story and my character was an easy decision, but a brutally painful one just the same. I have been working toward this goal for more than 30 years. It is all I have ever wanted: to see my work in print and to put the word “author” in front of my name. Perhaps this will turn out to have been my one opportunity to grab the brass ring. Unlike my character Ume Sky, I am no longer in my prime. But like Ume, I cannot be bought cheaply. I know the worth of what I’m selling.


Comments

9 responses to “Independence Day: Stranger than fiction”

  1. As you said – easy decision in this case, but difficult all the same. You must hang on to the dream and continue to persevere. You will see your work in print and you are already an author to me.
    This is an absolute outrage on the part of the publisher and I’m sorry you have been subjected to such a terrible experience.

    1. Thanks, LK. And thanks for the fabulous tea and sympathy today! :)
      (Damn, I wish I could figure out how to edit this template so that my comments weren’t in puce!) Update: Woohoo! Changed from puce to a less noxious pink. :)

  2. Damn, that sucks. It really, REALLY sucks.
    If it makes you feel any better, I endured something a little bit like this when I sold my first book to Silhouette Bombshell back in 2005. 15 months later (5 months prior to the book’s scheduled release date) my editor called to say Harlequin/Silhouette was canceling the Bombshell line one month before my book’s release date. I was out on my butt with my formerly contracted book plus two follow-ups I’d written that never made it to contract.

    It sucked, I won’t lie. And so did the next few years where I struggled to land somewhere and kept running into brick walls. But there is a happy ending, since I recently landed a three-book deal for my romantic comedies. While I sure as hell wish the road had been a bit smoother, I can admit now that I appreciate the good stuff a lot more than I would have it if had all come easy.

    Chin up, girl. You’ll land somewhere better for sure. When you do, you can gather us all together to flip the bird to your former publisher.

    Tawna

    1. Thanks, Tawna. Yikes, that does suck. I’m glad things eventually worked out for you. That’s a long time to be twisting in the wind; at least this was only three months.
      The Devil’s Garden goes back out on submission tomorrow, this time to print-only venues first. Ultimately, I’d like it to land somewhere that its companion novel could eventually be published as well.

  3. Hi Jane
    There’s a time and a place to bow to editorial requests…and this was not it. Brava! for keeping to your convictions.

    One editor loved it enough to offer a contract. I’m certain another will, too.

    Your story sounds fabulous. I can’t wait to read it…so keep us posted.

    Kelly

  4. I read about what happened from Tawna, and I just had to stop by your blog. It’s so horrible what they did, but I believe you did the right thing! If they had that problem, then they should have realized it from the very beginning. Your book is fiction and fantasy, so the character’s age shouldn’t matter.
    I had something similar happen to me too a year ago, and it still sometimes stings. I had one ebook out (a short story) and another ebook about to be published (another longer short story and about a week to be released) when the epublisher went under. We had very little warning, no real information, and were all just let go. It was a horrible experience, and it made me very wary to try again, but I did, and the one story that wasn’t published is supposed to be published in August. Hopefully. I still hold my breath, but I think everything will be fine this time.

    It’s one of the worst experiences when dealing with writing, and I don’t know if it is one you ever completely get over. But, it makes you wiser and more careful.

    I wish you the very best of luck placing The Devil’s Garden elsewhere. It sounds like a great book.

  5. Wow. Thanks for sharing your story… That’s definitely one of those things you never imagine happening, but once you hear about it, realize it probably does more than you can imagine.
    I’m sorry about your deal, but I’m sure you’ll find the right place for your book… a place that will appreciate the cultural nuances of your time & setting!

    Good luck!

  6. Wow, I actually teared up at the end of this post, reading you say that you knew the value of what you were selling. This was a great story for me to read right now.

  7. Thanks for all of the awesome comments. It really helps to know there are others who have been there, and I appreciate the encouragement to keep going. :)
    And extra-double thanks to Tawna for being such a sweetheart.

Leave a Reply